Science Explorer Back to mapMap

University-Industry-Government Innovation Models

University-Industry-Government Innovation Models is a research topic within Management of Technology and Innovation. Science Explorer counts 13k research works in it since 1954. 10.4% of them reached the world's top 10% most cited for their field and year.

This cluster of papers explores the concept of Quadruple Helix innovation ecosystems, emphasizing the interplay between academia, industry, government, and society in knowledge production and regional innovation systems. It delves into the dynamics of Triple Helix models, smart specialization strategies, and Mode 3 knowledge production, aiming to foster sustainable development and collaborative innovation within social systems.

  • Quadruple Helix
  • Innovation Ecosystem
  • Knowledge Production
  • Triple Helix
  • Regional Innovation Systems
  • Smart Specialization
  • Mode 3 Knowledge
  • University-Industry-Government Relations
  • Sustainable Development
  • Social Systems
Research works
13k
fractional, since 1954
In the world top 10%
1.4k
per year above
Top-10% rate
10.4%
share of its works in the world top 10%
Growth, 2018-21 → 2022-25
+37%
the tick is no change
Largest producer
China
17% of the 10 largest, 2022-now
University-Industry-Government Innovation Models

Which countries lead University-Industry-Government Innovation Models research?

By volume, China and Brazil publish the most (422 and 400 works in 2022-now).

By volume, 2022-now

  1. 1 China 422 works
  2. 2 Brazil 400 works
  3. 3 United States 332 works
  4. 4 Indonesia 258 works
  5. 5 Germany 222 works
  6. 6 Italy 193 works
  7. 7 United Kingdom 190 works
  8. 8 Russia 178 works
  9. 9 India 131 works
  10. 10 Spain 117 works

How concentrated that is

The same countries as shares of everything the list above accounts for. A node where two countries do two thirds of the work and one spread evenly across twelve read alike as a ranking and not at all alike here.

China: 17.3%Brazil: 16.4%United States: 13.6%Indonesia: 10.5%6 others listed: 42.2%17%largest
China422 · 17.3%Brazil400 · 16.4%United States332 · 13.6%Indonesia258 · 10.5%6 others listed1,032 · 42.2%

Shares of the rows listed above, not of the whole node.

Which institutions lead University-Industry-Government Innovation Models research?

By volume in 2022-now, Russian Academy of Sciences publishes the most University-Industry-Government Innovation Models research, followed by Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique and Universidade de São Paulo.

Who are the leading researchers in University-Industry-Government Innovation Models?

The most-cited researchers publishing on University-Industry-Government Innovation Models include Seeram Ramakrishna, Kathleen M. Eisenhardt and Joseph E. Stiglitz.

  1. 1 Seeram Ramakrishna Singapore 186k citations
  2. 2 Kathleen M. Eisenhardt United States 169k citations
  3. 3 Joseph E. Stiglitz United States 167k citations
  4. 4 Michael E. Porter United States 165k citations
  5. 5 Daron Acemoğlu United States 164k citations
  6. 6 David J. Teece United States 130k citations

Ranked by citations received across their whole record, among researchers with at least three works on this topic.

What are the most cited papers in University-Industry-Government Innovation Models?

The most cited paper in University-Industry-Government Innovation Models is "Knowledge of the Firm, Combinative Capabilities, and the Replication of Technology" (Bruce Kogut, Udo Zander, 1992), with 13,005 citations. Next come "The dynamics of innovation: from National Systems and “Mode 2” to a Triple Helix of university–industry–government relations" (8,566) and "Core capabilities and core rigidities: A paradox in managing new product development" (6,496).

Most cited papers
#PaperReleasedCitations
1 Knowledge of the Firm, Combinative Capabilities, and the Replication of Technology Bruce Kogut, Udo Zander · Organization Science Aug 1992 13,005
2 The dynamics of innovation: from National Systems and “Mode 2” to a Triple Helix of university–industry–government relations Henry Etzkowitz, Loet Leydesdorff · Research Policy Feb 2000 8,566
3 Core capabilities and core rigidities: A paradox in managing new product development Dorothy Leonard‐Barton · Strategic Management Journal 1992 6,496
4 Clusters and knowledge: local buzz, global pipelines and the process of knowledge creation Harald Bathelt, Anders Malmberg, Peter Maskell · Progress in Human Geography Open access Feb 2004 4,446
5 From sectoral systems of innovation to socio-technical systems Frank W. Geels · Research Policy Open access 15 May 2004 3,925
All 100 most cited papers, with filters and sorting

Where is University-Industry-Government Innovation Models research done?

The largest centres of University-Industry-Government Innovation Models research in 2022-now are Moscow (Russia), Beijing (China), London (United Kingdom) and São Paulo (Brazil).

Largest cities, 2022-now

  1. 1 MoscowRussia 87 works
  2. 2 BeijingChina 72 works
  3. 3 LondonUnited Kingdom 51 works
  4. 4 São PauloBrazil 47 works
  5. 5 BandungIndonesia 43 works
  6. 6 Rio de JaneiroBrazil 38 works
  7. 7 JakartaIndonesia 37 works
  8. 8 RomeItaly 35 works
  9. 9 ShanghaiChina 31 works
  10. 10 KyivUkraine 31 works
See University-Industry-Government Innovation Models on the map

Where is the best place to study University-Industry-Government Innovation Models?

Among universities, judged by research, Copenhagen Business School, Politecnico di Milano and National Research University Higher School of Economics score highest, combining citation excellence, specialisation, size, growth and international reach. Research strength is one signal when choosing where to study; it does not measure teaching.

0%20%40%mean 13.22%fractional works in this field (log) →share of work in the world top 10% →Lund UniversityPolitecnico di MilanoNational Research Un…Copenhagen Business …
above the meannear itbelow it

One dot per university in the first ten of the table below, at the default weights. The upper left is the interesting corner: small places doing unusually strong work.

Citation excellenceshare of its work in the world top 10%, 2022-now and all time averaged
40%
Specialisationhow much of its work is in this field, counted up to 10× the world share
10%
Sizeits output in this field, on a log scale
30%
Growthoutput growth, counted from -20% to +20%
10%
Internationalshare of its work with a co-author abroad
10%
Each slider sets a weight; the share it gets of the score is beside it.
#UniversityScoreTop 10%SpecialisationWorksGrowth
1Copenhagen Business SchoolDenmark 62.710.4%25.8×16 +101.3%
2Politecnico di MilanoItaly 62.713.0%5.4×15 +28.3%
3National Research University Higher School of EconomicsRussia 61.011.0%10.7×16 +10.6%
4Lund UniversitySweden 59.034.7%4.1×9 -22.8%
5Universidade de São PauloBrazil 54.55.0%2.4×19 +33.7%
6Tecnológico de MonterreyMexico 51.39.6%12.1×12 +16.0%
7Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do SulBrazil 49.010.4%4.6×14 +70.0%
8University of Naples Federico IIItaly 45.018.2%3.2×9 +89.0%
9University of JohannesburgSouth Africa 43.09.3%4.3×10 +156.0%
10Aalborg UniversityDenmark 40.910.6%5.1×11 -26.5%

Universities only. The score blends citation excellence (40%), size (30%), specialisation (10%), growth (10%), international reach (10%), 2022-now; growth compares 2018-21 with 2022-25 and counts up to +20%, since a jump from a small base is mostly noise.

Every institution in University-Industry-Government Innovation Models, country by country

Is University-Industry-Government Innovation Models research growing?

Output in 2022-2025 was 37% higher than in 2018-2021, peaking in 2025. The fastest-growing topics are University-Industry-Government Innovation Models.

still counting19801990200020102020
grewheldshrank

The same series as a ribbon: one cell per year, darker for more. The line above answers how much; this answers when.

Its share of all research

Growing output can still be a shrinking share: all of science grows. This is University-Industry-Government Innovation Models as a percentage of every work published that year, 0.018% in 2024.

still counting0.010%0.020%0.030%University-Industry-Government Innovation Models0.022% in 202519801990200020102020

Fractional works of University-Industry-Government Innovation Models over all fractional works that year. How the balance of science has shifted.

How much of it reaches the world top 10%

Year by year.

still counting5%10%15%University-Industry-Government Innovation Models10.8% in 2025200020102020

Of each year's works in it, the share that reached the world's 10% most cited for their field and year. A field is the world for its own topics, so there is no other line to hold it against.

Which topics inside it are moving

Growth and decline on one axis around a shared zero. Two lists side by side hide the thing that matters: whether the growth dwarfs the decline, or the other way round.

Discussion

Ask a question or share a note about University-Industry-Government Innovation Models. Keep it to the research: no personal attacks, advertising or links. Any reader can report a post, which collapses it for everyone until it is opened.